What a side letter changes
Every investor signs the same operating agreement or limited partnership agreement. A side letter sits beside it and gives one investor something the others do not have, usually because that investor is large, early or subject to rules of its own. The main agreement normally says that the sponsor may enter into side letters, and the offering documents disclose that it may. Common subjects are:
- Fees and promote: a lower management fee or a reduced promote for a large or early commitment.
- Reporting: extra reports, a particular format, or deadlines the investor's own auditors or regulators need.
- Co-investment: a right to be offered additional investments alongside the fund.
- Most favored nation (MFN): a right to see terms given to other investors and elect the ones that apply, often limited to investors of the same size or smaller.
- Transfers: permission to move the interest to an affiliate or a successor trust.
- Tax and regulatory terms: commitments that matter to tax-exempt investors or pension plans, for example.
A side letter example
A fund charges an asset management fee of 2% a year on each investor's contributed capital. An investor putting in $2,000,000 negotiates a side letter that reduces the fee to 1.5%. A second investor, with $250,000, has no side letter.
| Standard investor | Side letter investor | |
|---|---|---|
| Capital contributed | $250,000 | $2,000,000 |
| Fee rate | 2.0% | 1.5% |
| Yearly fee | $5,000 | $30,000 |
| Yearly fee at the standard rate | $5,000 | $40,000 |
| Yearly saving from the side letter | $0 | $10,000 |
Check the numbers
1.5% of $2,000,000 is $30,000, against $40,000 at the standard 2%, a saving of $10,000 a year. The discount has to be applied in every period for as long as the investor holds the interest, and again for anyone who elects the same term under an MFN clause.
Why side letters need tracking
Side letter terms live outside the main agreement, so they are easy to forget once the raise is over. Each one creates obligations with dates and amounts: a different fee, a report due sooner, a notice before a co-investment, an MFN election to offer. Sponsors keep a register of every side letter, the investor it belongs to and each obligation in it, and check a new side letter against the old ones before signing. A side letter that is signed and then left out of the fee and distribution calculations turns into a breach of contract.
A side letter cannot do everything. It has to be consistent with the governing agreement and with the duties the sponsor owes all investors, and how much must be disclosed to other investors depends on the documents and on securities rules. In smaller syndications, sponsors often create a separate class of interests with its own terms instead. Either way, have counsel review the terms before they are signed.