What the equity multiple measures
The equity multiple is the simplest return measure in real estate. It compares everything you get back with everything you put in. A 1.0x multiple means you got your money back and nothing more; 2.0x means you doubled it.
Its strength is that it is hard to dress up: it counts actual dollars. Its weakness is that it ignores time. Doubling your money in three years and in fifteen both show 2.0x.
Formula
Equity multiple = total distributions ÷ total equity invested.
What IRR measures
The internal rate of return is the annual rate that makes the present value of all a deal's cash flows, money in and money out, equal to zero. Put simply, it is the compound annual return the investment earned, taking into account exactly when each dollar moved.
Because it weighs time, IRR rewards getting money back sooner. Distributions in year one count for more than the same distributions in year seven.
Formula
IRR is the rate r for which the sum of each cash flow ÷ (1 + r) to the power of its year equals zero. Contributions are negative, distributions positive.
Why the two disagree: timing
Two deals can return exactly the same dollars and still have very different IRRs, because one returns them sooner. The multiple can't see the difference; IRR sees nothing else.
That is why neither number is enough alone. A high IRR on a small multiple can mean a quick flip that returned little money in total; a high multiple with a low IRR can mean a long wait.
Same multiple, different IRR: a worked example
Each deal below takes $100,000 and returns $180,000 in total, a 1.80x equity multiple. Only the timing differs.
Three deals with a 1.80x equity multiple
Deal A
- Invested
- $100,000
- Cash returned
- $180,000
- When it comes back
- $6,000 a year for 5 years, plus $150,000 at a sale in year 5
- Equity multiple
- 1.80x
- IRR
- 13.6%
Deal B
- Invested
- $100,000
- Cash returned
- $180,000
- When it comes back
- Nothing until a sale in year 3
- Equity multiple
- 1.80x
- IRR
- 21.6%
Deal C
- Invested
- $100,000
- Cash returned
- $180,000
- When it comes back
- Nothing until a sale in year 7
- Equity multiple
- 1.80x
- IRR
- 8.8%
Good to know
Deal B's IRR is simply 1.8 to the power of one third, minus 1: about 21.6% a year. Deal A pays the same total as C but returns some cash every year and finishes four years sooner, so its IRR is higher.
Cash-on-cash return
Cash-on-cash return measures the income a deal pays while you hold it: one year's cash distributions divided by the equity invested. Deal A above pays $6,000 a year on $100,000, a 6% cash-on-cash return.
It says nothing about the sale, which is where much of a value-add deal's profit usually comes from, so it complements the multiple and IRR rather than replacing them.
Watch for cash-on-cash figures that include a return of capital, such as a distribution of refinance proceeds. Those dollars raise the year's number without being income, so ask how a sponsor defines the figure before comparing deals.
IRR with real dates: XIRR
Textbook IRR assumes cash moves once a year. Real investors contribute and receive money on specific dates: a contribution in March, quarterly distributions, a capital call in year two, a sale in October.
XIRR, the version in Excel and Google Sheets, uses the actual dates and a daily clock. It is the right way to compute an individual investor's IRR, especially when their contributions and distributions don't line up with everyone else's.
How to read both, and their limits
A few habits make the numbers much more useful.
- Ask whether figures are projected or realized, and whether they are net of fees and the sponsor's promote.
- Read IRR alongside the hold period and the multiple; an early refinance can lift IRR while adding little total profit.
- Compare deals with similar risk and holding periods; a 15% IRR on a stabilized property and on a ground-up development are different bets.
- Before a sale, part of the return depends on an estimated current value; check how and when that value was set.
- IRR assumes cash can be reinvested at the same rate, which flatters very high IRRs on short deals.