What a syndication operating agreement governs
Most syndications create a new LLC for each deal, with the sponsor's entity as manager and the investors as non-managing members. State LLC law supplies default rules, but the operating agreement replaces most of them, and it stays in force for the life of the deal. For a limited partnership, the equivalent document is the limited partnership agreement. It typically covers:
- Capital contributions: what each member puts in, and the units or percentages they receive.
- Capital calls: whether the manager can require more money, and what happens to a member who doesn't fund, such as dilution or a member loan.
- Distributions: the waterfall, including the preferred return, return of capital and the sponsor's promote.
- Fees: what the sponsor and its affiliates are paid, on what base and when.
- Management and voting: the manager's authority, and the major decisions that need a vote of the members.
- Removal of the manager: the grounds, usually limited to cause, and the vote required.
- Transfers: restrictions on selling or assigning an interest, and what happens on death or divorce.
- Reporting: the financial statements, updates and tax documents the manager must provide, and members' rights to information.
- Tax matters: partnership tax treatment, how income and loss are allocated, capital accounts, and who serves as partnership representative.
Operating agreement vs PPM vs subscription agreement
Investors receive three documents and often read only one. Each does a different job.
The numbers in the offering materials, the financial model and the operating agreement have to agree. When a distribution is paid years later, it is the wording of the operating agreement that decides who gets what.
The operating agreement beside the other offering documents
Purpose
- Operating agreement
- Governs the company and its members
- Private placement memorandum
- Discloses the deal, its terms and its risks
- Subscription agreement
- Records one investor's purchase and representations
Kind of document
- Operating agreement
- Contract among the members and the manager
- Private placement memorandum
- Disclosure document
- Subscription agreement
- Contract between the investor and the company
Lasts
- Operating agreement
- For the life of the deal
- Private placement memorandum
- Used during the offering
- Subscription agreement
- Takes effect when the sponsor accepts it
If they conflict
- Operating agreement
- Usually controls
- Private placement memorandum
- Should match the operating agreement
- Subscription agreement
- Usually joins the investor to the operating agreement
Why a template is not enough for a syndication
Generic operating agreement templates are written for a small business owned by one person or a few partners. A syndication agreement has to do more: describe a multi-tier waterfall precisely, handle capital calls and defaults, carry the tax allocation provisions a partnership with a promote needs, and fit the securities exemption the offering relies on. A clause copied from another deal can contradict the terms investors were promised.
A template can be a useful list of topics to think about, but the agreement for a real offering is normally drafted by an attorney who handles securities and partnership tax matters, with the sponsor checking it line by line against the deal's terms. State requirements vary: some states require an LLC to adopt an operating agreement and many do not, and it is generally not filed with the state. Running a syndication without one would leave the state's default rules in charge.
Note
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. LLC law varies by state, and an operating agreement has to fit the deal, the securities exemption and the tax structure; have an attorney draft or review it.