How tenancy in common works
Tenants in common each own a percentage of the whole property, not a particular room or floor. One owner can hold 70% and another 30%, and each has the right to use the entire property. Each can generally sell, mortgage or give away their own share without the others' consent, unless they have agreed otherwise, and a co-owner who wants out can usually ask a court to divide the property or order a sale. Co-owners normally share income and expenses in proportion to their interests.
The details come from state property law and differ from state to state. A written co-ownership agreement covering expenses, decisions, a sale and what happens when someone wants to leave prevents most disputes. The form people most often confuse it with is joint tenancy:
| Tenancy in common | Joint tenancy | |
|---|---|---|
| Shares | Can be unequal | Equal |
| When an owner dies | The share passes under their will or state inheritance law | The share passes automatically to the surviving owners |
| Transfer by one owner | Generally allowed; the buyer becomes a tenant in common | Generally ends the joint tenancy for that share |
| Often used by | Unrelated co-investors, and relatives who want separate estates | Spouses and close family |
TIC investments and 1031 exchanges
In commercial real estate, a TIC investment is a property owned by several investors as tenants in common, usually organized by a sponsor. Because each investor holds title to real estate itself, each can generally use their interest in a section 1031 like-kind exchange, which an interest in a partnership or a typical LLC does not allow.
The risk is that a group of co-owners acting together is treated as a partnership for tax purposes. The IRS set out conditions for co-ownership arrangements in Revenue Procedure 2002-22, and sponsored TIC structures are commonly built around them, including a limit of 35 co-owners and co-owner approval of major decisions such as a sale, a lease or new financing. Lenders often add requirements of their own. TIC interests sold by a sponsor are generally treated as securities.
TIC vs LLC ownership
A TIC keeps each owner on title, which preserves exchange treatment but makes the property harder to run: decisions can need every co-owner's approval, and each owner's death, divorce or bankruptcy touches the title. An LLC puts title in one entity, with a manager in charge and decisions made under an operating agreement.
- Title: each co-owner in a TIC; the company in an LLC.
- Decisions: co-owner approval, often unanimous, in a TIC; the manager and the votes in the operating agreement in an LLC.
- 1031 exchange by an individual owner: generally possible in a TIC; generally not for an LLC member.
- Tax reporting: each TIC owner reports their own share; an LLC taxed as a partnership files Form 1065 and issues K-1s.
- Financing: a TIC loan involves every co-owner; an LLC is a single borrower.
Note
This guide is general information, not legal or tax advice. Co-ownership law varies by state, and the tax treatment of a TIC arrangement depends on its terms; have an attorney and a CPA review the structure.