How a Delaware statutory trust works
A sponsor forms the trust, buys a property (or several) in it, arranges any loan, and then sells beneficial interests to investors. The trust is the owner and the only borrower. Investors are passive: they have no vote on operations, do not sign the loan, and receive their share of the income. Their liability is generally limited under the Delaware statute.
DSTs are popular with owners who have sold a property and need replacement property quickly. A deferred exchange has short windows, generally 45 days to identify replacement property and 180 days to close, and a DST that is already assembled can be bought into within them. DST interests are generally securities and are usually offered to accredited investors in private placements under Regulation D.
The restrictions that come with the tax treatment
The tax treatment depends on the trust being a passive holder of property, not a business, so the trustee's powers are tightly limited once the offering closes. These limits make a DST a poor fit for a business plan that needs heavy renovation, re-leasing or a refinance.
Many trust agreements let the trustee convert the trust into an LLC if the restrictions would put the property at risk, which can affect investors' ability to exchange again. In general terms, the restrictions are:
- No new capital can be raised from investors after the offering closes.
- The trust cannot refinance or take on new borrowing, with narrow exceptions.
- Leases cannot be renegotiated and new leases cannot be signed, with narrow exceptions, which is why many DSTs lease the whole property to a master tenant.
- Sale proceeds cannot be reinvested; they are distributed to investors.
- Capital spending is limited to normal repairs, minor non-structural improvements and what the law requires.
- Cash, apart from reserves, is distributed currently, and reserves are kept in short-term investments.
DST vs TIC vs LLC syndication
Three structures let several investors own one property. Only two of them are generally compatible with a 1031 exchange by the individual investors.
Three ways for several investors to own one property
What the investor owns
- Delaware statutory trust
- A beneficial interest in the trust
- Tenancy in common
- An undivided interest in the property itself
- LLC syndication
- A membership interest in the LLC
1031 exchange by the investor
- Delaware statutory trust
- Generally eligible if the trust follows Revenue Ruling 2004-86
- Tenancy in common
- Generally eligible if the arrangement follows IRS guidance
- LLC syndication
- Generally not eligible
Number of investors
- Delaware statutory trust
- No 35-owner limit
- Tenancy in common
- Commonly limited to 35 co-owners
- LLC syndication
- No tax-law limit
Who decides
- Delaware statutory trust
- The trustee, within tight limits
- Tenancy in common
- The co-owners, often unanimously on major decisions
- LLC syndication
- The manager, with investor votes on listed matters
Room to refinance, re-lease or renovate
- Delaware statutory trust
- Very limited
- Tenancy in common
- Possible, with co-owner approval
- LLC syndication
- Flexible, under the operating agreement
Yearly tax reporting to the investor
- Delaware statutory trust
- Generally a statement of the investor's share of income and expenses, not a K-1
- Tenancy in common
- Each co-owner reports their own share
- LLC syndication
- Schedule K-1
Note
This guide is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Like-kind exchanges and DSTs have strict requirements not covered here; work with a qualified intermediary, a CPA and an attorney before relying on one.