The rule that decides where you can look
When investors put money into a deal and rely on you to run it, their interests are securities, and the offering needs an exemption from registration. Nearly every syndication uses one of two: Rule 506(b) or Rule 506(c) of Regulation D. Choose before you speak to anyone about the deal, because the choice sets who you may approach and how.
Under 506(b) you can't use general solicitation: no social media posts about the offering, no advertising, no pitching a room of strangers. You may offer the deal to people with whom you have a pre-existing, substantive relationship, meaning you knew them before the offering began and know enough about their finances and experience to judge whether it suits them. Under 506(c) you may advertise to anyone, but you may sell only to accredited investors and must take reasonable steps to verify that each one is.
| Rule 506(b) | Rule 506(c) | |
|---|---|---|
| Advertise the offering publicly | No | Yes |
| Who may invest | Accredited investors, plus up to 35 non-accredited investors who are financially sophisticated | Accredited investors only |
| How accredited status is established | The investor's own representations, if you reasonably believe them | Reasonable steps to verify: documents, a third-party letter, or a high minimum investment with written representations |
| Relationship needed before you offer | Pre-existing and substantive | None |
| Disclosure the rule prescribes | A specified set of documents if any non-accredited investor buys | None prescribed; the anti-fraud rules still apply |
| Suits | Sponsors raising from people they already know | Sponsors building an audience or raising from people they haven't met |
Good to know
An offering that has been advertised can't go back to 506(b). It can continue only under 506(c), with every later investor accredited and verified, so decide with securities counsel before the first post.
Where to find real estate investors: seven sources
Most first raises come from people the sponsor already knows. Later raises come increasingly from referrals and from an audience built between deals. The sources below are ordered roughly by how soon they tend to produce a first investment.
One source is missing on purpose: buying a list of accredited investors and e-mailing the offering to it. Under 506(b) that is general solicitation. Under 506(c) it is permitted, but people rarely wire five or six figures to a sponsor they first heard of in an unsolicited e-mail.
| Source | Works under | What it takes |
|---|---|---|
| Your own network: friends, family, colleagues, past clients | 506(b) and 506(c) | A list, a telephone and a clear account of what you do. Where most first raises begin |
| Referrals from current investors | Both; under 506(b), build your own relationship with the person referred before you offer | Deals that do what you said, reports that arrive on time, and asking |
| An audience you build: a newsletter, LinkedIn, a podcast, meetups, webinars | Both; under 506(b), teach in public and discuss a specific offering only in private, once a relationship exists | Months of consistent, useful content before the deal |
| Professionals: CPAs, attorneys, wealth advisers | Both | They introduce clients once they trust you. Don't pay a fee per investor |
| Co-sponsors and experienced partners | Both | A partner with a track record and investors of their own, with a real role in the deal |
| Family offices and private equity | Usually a negotiated joint venture rather than a syndication | A track record, larger deals and reporting to an institution's standard |
| The public: advertising, listings, platforms run by registered broker-dealers or funding portals | 506(c), or another exemption with its own limits such as Regulation Crowdfunding or Regulation A | Verification of every investor, a marketing budget and patience |
Build your investor list before you have a deal
The sponsors who close a raise quickly did the finding months earlier. Under 506(b) this is a legal requirement as much as a tactic: the relationship has to exist before the offering starts, so someone you meet after you begin raising generally waits for your next deal.
A relationship is substantive when you know enough to evaluate the person as a prospective investor: whether they are accredited, what they have invested in, how much they might put in, how long they can leave it there and what they want from it. The rule sets no waiting period. What counts is what you learned, and that you learned it before you made an offer. Keep a record.
- How and when you met, and the date of your first real conversation about their investing.
- Whether they are accredited, and on what basis: income, net worth, a professional license or an entity.
- Their experience: earlier private placements, real estate they own, their profession.
- What they are looking for: income or growth, a hold period, a typical amount.
- The state they live in, which decides the notice filing you owe, and how they would invest: personally, jointly, or through an LLC, a trust or a retirement account.
Good to know
A dated record of these conversations is the best evidence that a 506(b) offering wasn't generally solicited. A note written on the day of the call is worth more than a recollection two years later.
How many investors you need: the arithmetic of a raise
Work backwards from the equity. Divide the raise by the amount you expect a typical investor to put in, then allow for the people who say yes and never fund. The ratios below are assumptions for illustration; replace them with your own after a raise or two.
| Step | Assumption | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Equity to raise from investors | $2,000,000 | |
| Investors needed | An average investment of $100,000 | 20 investors |
| Soft commitments needed | 2 in 3 soft commitments fund | 30 soft commitments, $3,000,000 |
| People who review the deal | 1 in 3 who review it commit | 90 people |
| People on your list | 1 in 2 look at a given deal | 180 people |
Check the numbers
180 people × 1/2 × 1/3 × 2/3 = 20 investors, and 20 × $100,000 = $2,000,000. With a $50,000 average, every figure below the first row doubles.
What investors ask before they invest
Finding investors gets you a conversation. What turns it into a subscription is how well you answer the questions every experienced passive investor asks.
Put the answers in the offering documents and the data room, not only in conversation. What you tell investors has to match the private placement memorandum, and the anti-fraud rules apply to everything you say and write under every exemption: no projection presented as a promise, and no leaving out a fact a reasonable investor would want to know.
- Who are you, and what have you done? Deals bought, sold and still held, with real figures, including the ones that went badly.
- What is the plan, and what could go wrong? The price, the debt and when it matures, the budget, the assumptions about rents and the sale, and what happens if they are missed.
- How do you get paid? Every fee (acquisition, asset management, disposition and any other) and the promote.
- How do I get paid? The preferred return, the order of the waterfall, when distributions are expected and how long the money is tied up.
- How much of your own money is in the deal?
- What will I receive, and when? A report each quarter, a K-1 each spring, and a way to see my position without asking.
From first conversation to funded: the steps of a capital raise
A raise has the same stages whether it is $500,000 from twelve people or $20 million from two hundred. What changes is how much of it you can keep in your head, and how much has to be written down.
| Stage | What happens | What to keep |
|---|---|---|
| Before the deal | You build relationships with prospective investors | Dated notes on each person |
| Under contract | Counsel prepares the private placement memorandum, operating agreement and subscription agreement; you choose 506(b) or 506(c) | The offering's terms: minimum, maximum and closing date |
| Indications of interest | Eligible investors see the deal and say how much they might put in, without commitment | Who indicated, how much and when |
| Data room | Investors read the documents and ask questions | Who viewed what |
| Subscription | Investors complete the questionnaire and sign; in a 506(c) offering their accredited status is verified | Signed documents and the evidence of verification |
| Funding | Wires arrive against each subscription | The date and amount of each contribution |
| After the first sale | Form D is filed within 15 calendar days, and a notice in each investor's state as that state requires | Filing confirmations |
| Closing | Ownership is set, documents are countersigned and investors get access to the portal | The cap table as of the closing date |
What you can't do when raising capital
Most trouble in a raise comes from a short list of mistakes, each easy to make with good intentions.
- Pay commissions or finder's fees to people who aren't registered. Pay tied to the money someone brings in is the mark of a broker, and brokers have to be registered. That includes a 'capital raiser' added to the sponsor group whose only job is bringing investors and whose share depends on how much they raise. Give every member of the sponsor team a real, continuing role and have counsel review how each is paid.
- Promise or guarantee a return. A preferred return is an order of payment, not a guarantee, and a projection is a projection.
- Advertise a 506(b) offering, including by accident: a social post with the deal's terms, a podcast mention of the open raise, a public webinar that presents it.
- Take an investor's word for it in a 506(c) offering. A box ticked on a form isn't verification by itself.
- Involve a 'bad actor'. Rule 506 isn't available if the issuer or a covered person (a director, an officer, a 20% owner, a promoter or anyone paid to solicit investors) has a disqualifying event, such as certain securities-related convictions or orders. Ask each of them in writing.
- Forget the states. Rule 506 offerings don't register with the states, but most states require a notice filing and a fee once a resident invests.
Note
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Securities law turns on details, so work through the offering with a securities attorney before you raise.
The cheapest capital is a repeat investor
An investor who has been through a full cycle with you (subscribed, received reports and distributions when you said, had a K-1 in March and watched the deal do what you described) needs one conversation for the next deal, and often brings a friend. The work after the raise is part of finding investors.
- Report on a schedule: at least quarterly, and sooner when the news is bad.
- Pay distributions when you said you would, with a statement showing how each was worked out.
- Deliver K-1s early enough that investors aren't filing extensions on your account.
- Give investors one place to see their contributions, distributions, documents and returns.
- Tell them about the next deal before anyone else.