How preferred equity works in real estate
A preferred equity investor contributes capital to the company that owns the property, or to its parent, and receives a preferred membership interest. The operating agreement sets its return, how much of that return must be paid each month and how much may accrue, and the date by which the investment must be redeemed.
Preferred equity is not a loan, so there is no collateral to foreclose on. Its protection is contractual: if it is not paid or redeemed on time, the agreement may let the preferred investor take over management from the sponsor, block major decisions or force a sale. Terms range from debt-like, with fixed payment dates, to softer versions paid only from available cash flow.
A preferred equity example
A $12,000,000 purchase is funded with a $7,800,000 senior loan, $1,800,000 of preferred equity and $2,400,000 of common equity. The preferred equity earns 12% a year: 8% paid currently ($144,000 a year) and 4% accrued, without compounding, until it is redeemed at a sale after three years. The table shows who receives what from the sale, in a good outcome and a weak one.
| Paid at the sale, in order | Sale nets $14,000,000 | Sale nets $10,500,000 |
|---|---|---|
| Senior loan | $7,800,000 | $7,800,000 |
| Preferred equity: capital | $1,800,000 | $1,800,000 |
| Preferred equity: accrued return | $216,000 | $216,000 |
| Common equity | $4,184,000 | $684,000 |
Check the numbers
$14,000,000 − $7,800,000 − $1,800,000 − $216,000 = $4,184,000 for common equity. In the weaker sale the preferred equity is still paid in full, and common equity is left with $684,000 of its $2,400,000.
Preferred equity vs mezzanine debt vs preferred return
The three are easy to confuse because they share a word or a position. Preferred equity and mezzanine debt are separate layers of the capital stack, provided by a specialist investor or lender. A preferred return is a term inside the common equity that every investor in the class earns. In the documents, check the redemption date, what happens if it is missed, and whether the senior lender has approved the structure.
Preferred equity, mezzanine debt and preferred return compared
What it is
- Preferred equity
- An ownership interest with priority of payment
- Mezzanine debt
- A loan behind the senior mortgage
- Preferred return
- A term of the waterfall within common equity
Position
- Preferred equity
- After all debt, before common equity
- Mezzanine debt
- After senior debt, before all equity
- Preferred return
- Among common investors, before the sponsor's promote
Security
- Preferred equity
- None; rights come from the operating agreement
- Mezzanine debt
- A pledge of the ownership interests
- Preferred return
- None
If it is not paid
- Preferred equity
- Contractual remedies, such as taking over management
- Mezzanine debt
- Foreclosure on the pledged interests
- Preferred return
- It accrues if cumulative; there is usually no default
Share of the upside
- Preferred equity
- Usually little or none
- Mezzanine debt
- Usually none
- Preferred return
- Yes: holders also share in the profit