How a clawback provision works
A clawback matters when the sponsor is paid its promote before the fund's final result is known. That happens most often under a deal-by-deal, or American, waterfall: each property that sells at a profit pays the sponsor its share on that deal, even though later deals may lose money. If they do, the sponsor ends up holding more than its agreed percentage of the fund's overall profit.
The clawback fixes that at the end. When the fund is wound up, or at set points along the way, the whole fund's distributions are run through the agreed waterfall as if every dollar had been paid at once. If the sponsor received more promote than that calculation allows, it owes the difference back to the investors. Under a whole-fund, or European, waterfall the sponsor is paid last, so there is usually little or nothing to claw back.
Outside private funds the same word is used for other things, such as an employer taking back a bonus or a commission. This entry covers the fund and real estate meaning: promote or carry returned to investors.
A clawback example: three deals in one fund
A fund puts $4,000,000 into each of three properties, $12,000,000 in all. The sponsor's promote is 20% of profit, paid deal by deal. To keep the arithmetic visible there is no preferred return and no fee, and each deal's capital goes back to investors before any promote on that deal.
Deals A and B sell at a gain and pay the sponsor $600,000 of promote between them. Deal C then sells at a loss. Over the life of the fund the investors put in $12,000,000 and $13,500,000 comes back, a profit of $1,500,000, so the sponsor's agreed share is 20% of $1,500,000, or $300,000.
A deal-by-deal waterfall with a clawback at the end of the fund
Year 2: deal A sells for $6,000,000
- Gain or loss
- $2,000,000
- Investors
- $5,600,000
- Sponsor
- $400,000
Year 4: deal B sells for $5,000,000
- Gain or loss
- $1,000,000
- Investors
- $4,800,000
- Sponsor
- $200,000
Year 6: deal C sells for $2,500,000
- Gain or loss
- −$1,500,000
- Investors
- $2,500,000
- Sponsor
- $0
Before the clawback
- Gain or loss
- $1,500,000
- Investors
- $12,900,000
- Sponsor
- $600,000
Clawback
- Investors
- +$300,000
- Sponsor
- −$300,000
Final
- Gain or loss
- $1,500,000
- Investors
- $13,200,000
- Sponsor
- $300,000
Check the numbers
$13,200,000 to investors and $300,000 to the sponsor add up to the $13,500,000 the fund returned. The sponsor ends with 20% of the $1,500,000 profit and investors with 80%, the same as a whole-fund waterfall would have given, but only if the $300,000 is actually paid back.
Clawback vs escrow or holdback
A clawback is a promise to repay later. An escrow, or holdback, keeps part of each promote payment in the fund or in a separate account until the end, so there is money on hand if a clawback comes due. Many agreements use both: a share of the promote is held back, and the clawback covers anything the holdback doesn't.
The difference matters because a clawback is only as good as the sponsor's ability to pay. By the time it is tested, the promote may have been spent, distributed to the sponsor's own partners or used to pay tax on it.
What to check in a clawback provision
The fund's operating agreement or limited partnership agreement sets every detail. Points that change what investors can actually recover:
- When it is tested: only when the fund is wound up, or also at interim points such as after each sale.
- Net of taxes: whether the amount owed is reduced by tax the sponsor's members paid on the promote they received.
- Who stands behind it: the sponsor entity alone, or also its principals, each for their own share or for the whole amount.
- Escrow: whether part of each promote payment is held back, and when it is released.
- What counts: whether fees, fund expenses and the preferred return are included when the final waterfall is run.